|
Post by tisbearself on Dec 5, 2023 15:18:00 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Dominic on Dec 5, 2023 20:06:02 GMT
Are they all from Ireland or imported from Poland or Africa? More likely Africa than Poland. Poland is rapidly secularizing and the number of vocations has plummeted precipitously there. Young priests are also quitting in high numbers, so Poland is exporting a lot fewer priests than it used to. I'm also guessing that, like in the UK, most Poles in Ireland don't normally attend regular Irish parish Masses in English, but rather Masses in Polish under the auspices of the Duszpasterstwo Polskie w Irlandii (Polish Chaplaincy in Ireland), which is a sort of a parallel church structure that organizes Masses for Poles in cooperation with Irish diocesan and religious parishes, but outside of the usual local diocesan structure. Kind of like an exarchate, the priests that serve them are not incardinated into local dioceses. As for 15 vs 0, they had likely been deferring candidates for a few years until they could assemble a class of a manageable size. This has been done in Germany and the Netherlands before.
|
|
|
Post by theguvnor on Dec 6, 2023 21:32:02 GMT
Yes, a lot of the Poles in London attend Masses in Polish as well, they tend to lean towards the trad end of things.
|
|
|
Post by Dominic on Dec 7, 2023 0:58:40 GMT
Yes, a lot of the Poles in London attend Masses in Polish as well, they tend to lean towards the trad end of things. If by "trad", you have in mind either a preference for the TLM, or hostility to Vatican II, then no. Neither has any traction among Polish Catholics, even of the most conservative variety. The very tiny TLM community in Poland is practically invisible and attracts only a miniscule fringe, a few hundred individuals at the most, if that. Poles are rarely nostalgic about the pre-Vatican II Church. It's rarely even thought or talked about. It's certainly not viewed in terms of some kind of "Golden Age" to be longed for. If on the other hand, you mean very conservative, then yes. Moderates and liberals have mostly already abandoned the Church, and even the center right is falling away, leaving mostly the far right and alt-right, especially in the younger generations that would immigrate. Catholicism in Poland is highly politicized, very much like White Evangelicalism in the US. Actually, the resemblance is quite eerie.
|
|
|
Post by blackforest on Dec 7, 2023 5:18:50 GMT
Just speaking personally here, but I feel uncomfortable keeping score on who's "trad" or "progressive." The bottom line is that they're men called by God to serve as priests - in Ireland, at that. I frequently tune into Fr. Thady Doyle's Youtube channel, and from what he describes, it's a godsend to round up *that many* seminarians there. It *would* be interesting to know where they're from, however.
|
|
|
Post by tisbearself on Dec 7, 2023 5:37:49 GMT
I do not use the word "trad" to refer solely to whether they want to say Mass in TLM. More interested in overall outlook as I just read a separate article in which some older lady who holds a position at Knock expressed some very progressive German-bishop ideas about Irish church governance and I was curious to know if the younger clergy coming up felt same as her. I am guessing probably not, but given that these are just seminarians it may be too soon to tell.
If someone is uncomfortable with my use of "trad" or any other term, that's not really my problem, but theirs.
Getting back to the actual subject of the thread, I was also told by an Irish person elsewhere that there are also 30 deacons in training in Ireland and that there seems to be an uptick in vocations there, which is good news if so. I pray that the uptick continues.
|
|
|
Post by Dominic on Dec 7, 2023 14:39:17 GMT
It *would* be interesting to know where they're from, however. Me, too. It's very difficult if not impossible to find out. Foreign priests, especially those from Africa or Asia, are a sensitive topic, and the Church tries to keep them on the "down low", so to speak. Out of sight, out of mind. For two reasons. One is that they're afraid that it will scare off native potential candidates. The other is that parishes that end up with a foreign pastor often perceive it as a sign that they are not priorities for the local ordinary, and may be slated for closure or merger in the near future. Especially if the pastor in question is from a third-world country. I've heard such discussions in the past: "Saint Michael's just got a pastor from Nigeria!" "Uh oh! You know what means!" There's a growing perception in Europe, and also somewhat in the US, Canada and Australia, that Catholicism is transforming from a "European" religion to an "African" one, from a "native" one to a "foreign" one. That is a big problem in Europe, where religion has long been tightly linked to ethnic and national identity, often more so than to actual religious identity. Most people who identify as Catholic in Europe are not practicing, or even believing, Catholics, but rather "Cultural Catholics". Yes, it's partially due to prejudice, but more so to economics and culture rather than to overt racism. It's not as visible yet as the divide between the "Global North" and the "Global South" in the Anglican Communion, but it's eventually going to go along the same path, though a bit slower because the Catholic Church is far more centralized.
|
|
|
Post by homeschooldad on Dec 7, 2023 15:33:28 GMT
It *would* be interesting to know where they're from, however. Especially if the pastor in question is from a third-world country. I've heard such discussions in the past: "Saint Michael's just got a pastor from Nigeria!" "Uh oh! You know what means!" Forgive me, but that is flying right over my head. What does that "mean"?
|
|
|
Post by homeschooldad on Dec 7, 2023 15:43:12 GMT
I do not use the word "trad" to refer solely to whether they want to say Mass in TLM. More interested in overall outlook as I just read a separate article in which some older lady who holds a position at Knock expressed some very progressive German-bishop ideas about Irish church governance and I was curious to know if the younger clergy coming up felt same as her. I am guessing probably not, but given that these are just seminarians it may be too soon to tell. If someone is uncomfortable with my use of "trad" or any other term, that's not really my problem, but theirs. Getting back to the actual subject of the thread, I was also told by an Irish person elsewhere that there are also 30 deacons in training in Ireland and that there seems to be an uptick in vocations there, which is good news if so. I pray that the uptick continues. With the growth of the TLM and its appeal to a broader cross-section of people, it's increasingly difficult to pigeon-hole its adherents. I am basically traditional in outlook and I seek out the TLM as my Mass of choice, but I favor optional clerical celibacy (at least for men above a certain age and of a good station in life, viz. viri probati), have no intrinsic problem with Mass in a reverent, dignified vernacular, and if it weren't for abortion and Second Amendment issues, my politics would more resemble those of Bernie Sanders or AOC, i.e., raise taxes and provide very broad social benefits for the whole of society. Nobody should be homeless, hungry, or without health care, nor should they have to fear financial ruin if they can't afford the latter without destroying what they've worked to save in life. I have no issue with "thread drift", and there is always the option of splitting out a thread if it starts departing wildly from its original subject. I don't think that's happened here yet, but if it does, that's fine.
|
|
|
Post by tisbearself on Dec 7, 2023 16:06:09 GMT
I like to attend TLM but am politically somewhere between moderate and apolitical, except on pro-life where I’d probably be called a conservative for following the Church teaching. A few years ago some then-friend of mine who was way too into politics to the point where it was keeping them up nights worrying called me a “libertarian” and I’m still trying to figure out where that idea came from, as I didn’t even know what that was and still not sure, nor do I care to be honest as I find politics boring except when there’s a fun rally or party.
The vast majority of Masses I attend are OF and are perfectly good Masses, I like a variety and have also attended Ordinariate Mass, Dominican Rite Mass, Charismatic Mass, hoping to add Carmelite Rite Mass to my list in the near future. All Masses have some nice attendees and annoying attendees, that is how life is and we are called to be kind to all.
|
|
|
Post by homeschooldad on Dec 7, 2023 16:56:23 GMT
I like to attend TLM but am politically somewhere between moderate and apolitical, except on pro-life where I’d probably be called a conservative for following the Church teaching. A few years ago some then-friend of mine who was way too into politics to the point where it was keeping them up nights worrying called me a “libertarian” and I’m still trying to figure out where that idea came from, as I didn’t even know what that was and still not sure, nor do I care to be honest as I find politics boring except when there’s a fun rally or party. The vast majority of Masses I attend are OF and are perfectly good Masses, I like a variety and have also attended Ordinariate Mass, Dominican Rite Mass, Charismatic Mass, hoping to add Carmelite Rite Mass to my list in the near future. All Masses have some nice attendees and annoying attendees, that is how life is and we are called to be kind to all. I am moderate to liberal on most social issues, again, abortion and Second Amendment rights aside. As to same-sex marriage, no, I cannot approve of two men or two women being united in something called "marriage", though I could reluctantly condone some kind of civil union, with rights to inheritance, next-of-kin issues, insurance, pensions, and so on, as two people choosing to unite their fortunes is about far more than just having sex with each other. If they want to get a civil union and then hie themselves off to some celebrant, have a ceremony, and call it a "marriage", well, we can't police the world. As to someone such as AOC decrying how we can have the richest country in the world and still have children getting ringworm, conservatives lampooned her for this, but I echo her thoughts entirely. I keep my mouth shut (yes, I'm capable of doing that, mirabile dictu) about my more liberal political views when among hard-right TLMers, and I peeled off my Bernie Sanders bumper sticker in 2016 before I parked my car in the lot of the TLM church one Sunday (I supported him simply because he wasn't Hillary, IMO he was the lesser of two evils). That could harsh some people's mellow.
|
|
|
Post by blackforest on Dec 7, 2023 17:53:47 GMT
If someone is uncomfortable with my use of "trad" or any other term, that's not really my problem, but theirs. I don't really think I have a "problem." I just wanted to point out in the wake of some widespread schismatic sentiments of late, divisive, either-or framing probably isn't helpful to our Church. These seminarians are hopefully all over the map and see some nuance to the many issues affecting our faith. At this point, I'm elated that Ireland is seeing *any* seminarians with so many priests there retiring.
|
|
|
Post by blackforest on Dec 7, 2023 17:58:35 GMT
Especially if the pastor in question is from a third-world country. I've heard such discussions in the past: "Saint Michael's just got a pastor from Nigeria!" "Uh oh! You know what means!" Forgive me, but that is flying right over my head. What does that "mean"? I'm a little curious, myself. In my own church, it means, "Uh-oh! I hope we understand this guy . . . " We had one Nigerian priest who was completely unintelligible. After two years of rigorous study, however, it's no longer been a problem.
One of his homilies, (an understandable one) made me reflect on the irony of our church now needing Africa to come Christianize the West! I remember reading somewhere that Nigeria is now the most Catholic country in the world. Perhaps their zeal and passion are just what the Big Doctor ordered for the Catholic Church in the U.S. I, for one, love how the infusion of foreign priests is shaking up our Church . . . in a positive way. Hopefully we see something similar in Ireland.
|
|
|
Post by tisbearself on Dec 7, 2023 18:53:17 GMT
I peeled off my Bernie Sanders bumper sticker in 2016 before I parked my car in the lot of the TLM church one Sunday (I supported him simply because he wasn't Hillary, IMO he was the lesser of two evils). That could harsh some people's mellow. Last rally I went to was actually The Bern, LoL. He was not running for anything. I just went to see what was going on down there. I found his mittens shtick at the last 'naug to be amusing. I do not put any kind of political sign on my car or property, it just encourages vandalism. If I want to wave a sign I will take it to an event or a demonstration and wave it there, which I have done from time to time.
|
|
|
Post by Dominic on Dec 7, 2023 20:21:17 GMT
Forgive me, but that is flying right over my head. What does that "mean"? I'm a little curious, myself. Follows from the preceding sentences: "The other is that parishes that end up with a foreign pastor often perceive it as a sign that they are not priorities for the local ordinary, and may be slated for closure or merger in the near future. Especially if the pastor in question is from a third-world country."
|
|